|
Brief Synopsis:
The Quiet American, originally published in 1955, is set in Vietnam
during the last days of French rule. It tells the story of a developing
friendship between Fowler, a middle-aged British journalist working
in Saigon, and Pyle, a young "quiet American" who has
come to Vietnam full of idealism. Fowler and Pyle's relationship
becomes fraught on several levels: a triangle develops involving
Fowler's Vietnamese mistress; and more problematically, Pyle's idealism
leads him into questionable political policies and, ultimately,
bloodshed.
Called the most famous Western work of fiction about Vietnam, The
Quiet American delicately balances issues of personal responsibility
and the global consequences of our choices. In particular, Pyle--about
whom Fowler says, "I never knew a man who had better motives
for all the trouble he caused"--becomes a catalyst for broader
questions of the morality of colonialism and war.
Discussion Questions:
1. Is it possible that Fowler remains neutral in the Vietnam/French
relationship? Is it
ever possible not to take a side?
2. How does Pyle justify his own deception, yet scorn Fowler for
misleading Phuong? Is it possible to distinguish between the two
lies?
3. Why does Greene go to such lengths to portray Pyle as innocent
yet deceived?
4. Fowler says of Pyle and the priest, "You can't blame the
innocent, they are
always guiltless" but later asks, "How many dead colonels
justify a
child's or a trishaw driver's death?" (163). How does Fowler
distinguish between the army's spreading of democracy and the priest's
propagation of religion?
|